US vs Canada: Pay transparency, equity, and opportunity in 2024 with Game Plan Total Rewards

In our latest webinar, Sean Raible from Game Plan Total Rewards Consulting, Charlie Franklin, and our guests explored the evolving landscape of pay transparency and equity in the US and Canada. 

As companies strive to attract and retain top talent, understanding the regulatory nuances and market challenges and opportunities in compensation becomes paramount. 

As the leader of the company that helps organizations design and deliver market-competitive compensation and benefits solutions - Sean Raible provided valuable insights on how organizations can navigate these complexities to foster effective comp practices. 

The webinar explored the differences (and similarities) between the US and Canadian markets concerning compensation regulations and trends. 

Sean and Charlie discussed the balancing act required to bridge the gap between the equitable and inequitable aspects of total rewards programs, emphasizing the need for strategic analysis of market trends and drivers. 

The conversation also focused on the importance of optimizing comp strategies to establish a competitive edge by leveraging pay transparency to not only comply with regulations - but also to attract and retain top talent. 

‍

Navigating the differences in compensation between the US and Canada

One of the most significant differences between compensation in the US and Canada lies in the legislative landscape. 

Sean explained that Canada’s regulations are influenced by both federal and provincial laws, creating a complex environment that requires careful navigation. 

As Sean highlighted, many US companies mistakenly assume that American employment rules will apply in Canada, leading to significant misunderstandings. To avoid these pitfalls, it’s crucial to understand the unique legislative context and seek local expertise. 

Canada’s strong emphasis on diversity, equity, and inclusion, as well as active efforts toward reconciliation with Indigenous communities, sets it apart from the US. These policies around diversity and inclusion are not just statements - they are actively implemented and observed. 

‍

Why Canada might be at the global forefront 

Sean believes that Canada is at the forefront of implementing inclusive and transparent pay practices, which offer valuable lessons for global adoption. 

Canada’s practices not only ensure compliance but also ensure that compensation policies are equitable. The forward-thinking approach can serve as a model for companies worldwide, highlighting the importance of connecting comp strategies to DE&I (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) initiatives.  

Sean emphasized that companies can create more equitable and inclusive workplaces, ultimately enhancing their global competitiveness by implementing these practices. 

‍

Building inclusive comp frameworks

Sean highlighted the critical role of data in driving equitable compensation practices. He explained that by collecting and analyzing demographic data, companies can identify and address systemic biases in their comp practices. 

“The more data we have - the more we can start to see” - Sean noted. 

For instance, understanding how different social factors (such as gender identity or Indigenous status) impact pay equity enables organizations to implement targeted interventions. 

The data-driven approach does more than just promote fairness. It helps companies align their strategies with broader DEI goals, ensuring that all employees are treated equitably. 

‍

Market trends in comp: Pensions and layoffs

Charlie and Sean discussed some of the most interesting recent trends - such as an increased interest in retirement plans. 

As financial stress and the cost of living continue to rise, even higher-income employees are re-evaluating their retirement savings options. 

Sean noted that employees earning $100,000 or more are seeking better retirement options, prompting organizations to rethink their retirement offerings. The trend also serves as a retention tool, adding value to employment packages and encouraging long-term commitment from employees. 

Charlie noted that the insight is interesting, especially keeping in mind that “everybody’s focused on cost” in the US currently - according to the market data that Compa’s tools provide. 

Sean shared his belief that companies in Canada are facing similar challenges, which can best be seen through layoffs and budget constraints. He explained that the market is experiencing a cautious approach to spending, with many organizations also being mindful of over-reducing their workforce. 

Sean noted that “the sensitivity around how it’s done” is crucial. Overly aggressive layoffs, as he explained, can lead to rehiring challenges and negative public perceptions. 

‍

Strategic shifts in talent acquisition

To manage costs while remaining competitive, many companies are exploring lower-cost locations for their operations. 

Sean and Charlie discussed how traditional R&D hubs like the Bay Area and New York are being supplemented or replaced by presences in more affordable regions, including parts of Eastern Europe, India, and increasingly, Canada. 

Establishing offices in cities like Toronto and Vancouver allows companies to tap into a highly skilled workforce while mitigating the high costs and immigration challenges associated with US locations. 

They both agreed that the strategic shift not only helps in managing expenses but also leverages the rich talent pools available in these regions. 

‍

Access the full webinar to hear about other topics Sean and Charlie discussed, such as why many organizations are re-evaluating their variable pay structures. 

‍Subscribe to our Peer Group newsletter to discover more insightful conversations.